A Monday decision by the U.S. Supreme Court – a unanimous one at that – signaled trouble for the NCAA and the colleges who have benefitted from “amateur athletes” for generations.
The ruling was specific to a case that involved confirming a lower court’s ruling that athletes can accept compensation for some things – like musical instruments or internships, for instance – that can be paid for and not be penalized. This wasn’t involving the other case for play-for-pay, but even the justices called out an organization that needs change in the worst possible way.
From Justice Brett Kavanaugh:
“The NCAA’s business model would be flatly illegal in almost any other industry in America.”
And:
“Everyone agrees that the NCAA can require student-athletes to be enrolled students in good standing. But the NCAA’s business model of using unpaid student-athletes to generate billions of dollars in revenue for the colleges raises serious questions under the antitrust laws.”
Now, this is uber-conservative, I like beer and free markets Justice Brett Kavanaugh writing this concurring opinion. Justice Neil Gorsuch was harsh too in the main opinion.
Gorsuch wrote:
“Put simply, this suit involves admitted horizontal price fixing in a market where the defendants exercise monopoly control.”
I would expect to read that about some company like Facebook, not college sports. Yet that’s finally where this strange situation lands us. I finally think maybe the Supreme Court is willing to stick up for kids who deserve better than what they have been promised.
Here’s the big issue at hand: for decades, the NCAA’s puritanical rules and stipulations over college athletics have turned student-athletes into essentially unpaid professionals like the NFL, NBA, NHL, WNBA, Arena Football, MLS, and others (think tennis, golf, etc.) use university programs as their minor league farm systems.
This happens because student-athletes who sign D-I scholarships are forced to abide by rules not allowing anyone to make any kind of additional money. No endorsements, no summer league pay, no jobs outside of school. The only money the school provides is allowed.
Additionally, until recent times, athletes also signed away rights to their names and likeness in perpetuity. Meaning those players used on the front of NCAA Football game boxes back in the day? Reggie Bush didn’t make any dollars off that. I believe those rules changed last year.
Throughout the decades, college athletes (especially in football) also only received help for the cost of medical care so long as they remained players with scholarships. Once they were cut from the team, those bad knees and ankles, broken bones, and multiple concussions are the problem of the student-athlete who also loses their scholarship when their usefulness is at an end and they are cut from the team.
On the flip side, the NCAA and colleges together make billions in TV deals, licensing and merchandising, and off tuition from regular students. March Madness makes the NCAA $1 billion annually.
Looking at the situation with logic in mind, doesn’t it stand to reason the NCAA could cover any Student athlete payments just from the Men’s basketball tournament alone? I’m not including college football or any regular season licensing deals they make either.
The world in which the rules over college athletes being allowed to play for pay are long ago and far away, a time when the cost to attend universities was – even adjusted for inflation – comically much lower than average annual tuition at a school today.
Let’s not kid ourselves either: the money is a driving factor as to why they don’t want to do this. The licensing fees the NCAA receives from corporations like Disney and Viacom get used to fund scholarships and are divided up between the member schools. The big-named schools – Alabama, Georgia, Kentucky, Kansas, Texas, USC for instance – make a lot of their own money too.
There is no reason other than greed why the NCAA and colleges couldn’t come together to figure out an equitable and still perfectly balanced way to make sure college athletes aren’t being traded an education they might never use – and from what I saw back in the day at Auburn and have read time and again in investigative reporting is that academics are a joke anyhow for a lot of college athletes (not all, of course.) They use rules established in a time when college athletes could afford not to be paid to continue to hold an unfair advantage over those doing the real work in sports we enjoy. That’s in part why antitrust laws were created.
If the NCAA wants to keep the delusion going that they can continue this system without backlash from the government, they are sadly mistaken. Yet if the treatment of Major League Baseball during the steroids era is any indication, they might get off lightly with smacks on the hand and be given leeway to figure out their legal woes with college athletes on their own.
The easiest way for them to avoid future headaches would be the following: a real monthly stipend of some amount to allow a college athlete to live like a normal human being – say $3,000 – and place a larger lump sum that can be negotiated on an individual basis into trust to be paid out upon completion of an academic degree. Still give them free tuition, board and cafeteria food. Still impose harsh rules for boosters enticing youth to play for a team, and actually enforce them. The NCAA shouldn’t be afraid under those circumstances of creating another SMU situation, since players would still be making money one way or another.
Also, impose the same monthly payment for all athletes, no matter their sport or gender. Sure, we might not give much of our attention to college volleyball or crew, but these activities provide just as much opportunity for students to excel as football, and they have to do the same amount of traveling, studying, and practice like any other sport.
I’m sure you, my friendly reader, agree these are ways the NCAA can make positive changes that will help student-athletes in the future and not break the bank. If anything, it might spark a greater level of competition among schools to get the best and brightest if they can attract student-athletes with the lump sums for finishing school and not leaving after their junior year for professional contracts of millions of dollars.
My hope is the courts and congress don’t need to get involved further, and that this can be resolved in a manner beneficial to all. Otherwise, the NCAA is likely to become a high-profile victim of changing times to everyone’s detriment.
-Kevin the Editor